American Employment Growth Justifies Fed Caution

  • Non-Farm Payrolls in October exceeded expectations
  • The only concern is manufacturing which continues to struggle
  • The Fed seems justified in pausing on rates for now
  • The declines durable goods orders and a build of excess capacity will need watching

Non-Farm Payrolls in the U.S. is arguably the most important economic statistic in the world. It possesses the ability to move the U.S. Treasury and Wall Street equity markets and so, it follows, move all other markets in a way that no other metric can.

Indeed, I would go as far as to say the October data when released on the first Friday of November can do more than any other data point to determine how markets will trade into the year end.

The reading for October 2019 rose by 128,000, following an upwardly revised 180,000 increase in September (from 136,000). This was far in excess of market expectations of just 89,000. The sectors that saw most gains in employment were food services, beverage outlets, social assistance, and financial services.

The one notable flat spot was found in manufacturing where employment in the motor vehicles and parts sector declined by 42,000. This was the most in a decade due to strike activity at GM plants in Michigan and Kentucky. Striking employees are treated as unemployed in the US statistics. Overall the data suggests that some 60,000 jobs were affected in one way or another by the GM strike.

NFP and UE 02-11-19

Figure 1: U.S. Non-Farm Payroll (‘000) and Unemployment Rate (%)
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics

Job growth so far this year has averaged just 167,000 a month, down from an average of 223,000 in 2018, according to official figures from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS).

President Trump should be mildly pleased that the payrolls exceed expectation as it adds to the fact that since the President’s 2016 election, the economy has added over 6.7 million jobs. The White website said:

 “…States across the country continue setting record-low unemployment rates, showing how Federal policies that support economic growth benefit local communities. …”

The president took to Twitter to say:

“… Wow, a blowout JOBS number just out, adjusted for revisions and the General Motors strike, 303,000. This is far greater than expectations. USA ROCKS!…”

No one seems quite sure about his 300,00+ figure, however, what he will be sure to point out in the election campaign next year is that many states are printing record low unemployment figures.

WH States and UE Rates 02-11-19

Figure 2: States and Low Unemployment

Despite the impressive payrolls growth, the US unemployment rate increased to 3.6% in October 2019 from 3.5% in the previous month. This was in line with market expectations. Over the month, the number of unemployed persons increased by 86,000.

U.S. average hourly earnings for all employees on private Non-Farm Payrolls rose by 6 cents, or 0.2% from the prior month to $28.18 in October 2019, after being unchanged in September and slightly below market expectations of 0.3%.

US Avg Hourly Earnings 02-11-19

Figure 3: U.S. Average Hourly Earnings (%)
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics

This October employment report supports Fed Chairman Jerome Powell’s assessment this week that the U.S. economic outlook remains solid and the job market is strong.

The Fed slashed the target range for the federal funds rate to 1.50 -1.75% during its October meeting, the third rate cut so far this year, given the muted inflation pressures and concerns about the economic outlook. However, at the same time, it signalled a pause in easing cycle as the previous reference that it “will act as appropriate” to sustain the economic expansion was removed from the policy statement.

Over the last 15 meetings to September 2019, Fed Funds futures have priced an average around 2 bps away from the target rate, with a maximum divergence of 11 bps when moves of 50-75 bps occurred on a regular basis. The two outliers arose in January and October 2008, when the Federal Reserve made emergency cuts totalling 125 and 100 bps for those months.

In the short-term, some of the exogenous risks the Fed had worried about have moved to a relative state of calmness as the trade standoff with China is not as aggressive as at the start of the year. However, endogenous factor are proving to be a concern.

New orders for U.S. manufactured durable goods fell 1.1% from a month earlier in September 2019, following an upwardly revised 0.3% gain in the previous month, c.f. market expectations of -0.8%. Transportation equipment led the decline after three consecutive monthly increases.

U.S. retail sales fell 0.3% from a month earlier in September 2019, after an upwardly revised 0.6% gain in August and missing market expectations of a 0.3% increase. This marked the first decline in retail activity since February, mainly due to lower sales at motor vehicles, building materials, hobbies and online purchases.

With the level of capacity utilisation in the U.S. declining to 77.50% in September from 77.90% in August the use of existing productive potential is well down from the average of 80.23% from 1967 until 2019. Given the amount of free headroom business has it is not a surprise to see a pullback on fixed investment.

Four Charts USA 03-11-19

Figure 4: U.S. Durable Goods Orders, Retail Sales, Capacity Utilisation and Federal Funds
Source: Census Bureau, Federal reserve

However, the real takeaway is that the American employment market is holding up well. Consumer spending increased to $13.344 Trillion in the third quarter of 2019 from $13.250 Trillion in Q2 as personal income increased 0.3% in September 2019.

Therefore, even though the government estimated that the economy grew in the July-October quarter at a modest annual rate of 1.9% the equity markets, Dow + 301.13 +1.11%, S&P500 +29.35 +0.97% and NASDAQ + 94.04 +1.13% did not appear too fearful given the U.S. economy has been expanding for more than a decade, the longest period of growth on record.

It seems the markets are content as long as there is no signals to suggest the consumer is losing any momentum. So, the Fed can be relaxed about being on hold for a while as the markets like the data and the T2/T10 spread has settled at +16bps from reading -1 bps on August 30.

Macroeconomic Strategist

Stephen Pope is the Managing Partner of Spotlight Group. He has worked in the world of finance since 1982 and has performed d... Continued

Comments on this analysis

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Related News

Global Markets Outlook 2021

Initial Parameters: Chart analysis is technical and taken from medium-term historical patternTechnical projections based on a twelve-month time horizonTargets set are based on the most recent, significant technical adjustmentAnalysis is based on Elliot Wave and Fibonacci techniquesTechnical analysis only guides; exogenous factors can shock any marketMarkets, being capricious, forecasts are subject to revisionFundamental analysis can be commissioned on requestEquity sector analysis is thematic United States… Continued

Minor Correction Underway – Market Turning Points

Cycles:  Looking ahead!  90-yr cycle – last low: 1932. Next low: 2022 7-yr cycle – last low: 2016.  Next low: 2023 Market Analysis (Charts courtesy of QCharts SPX-IWM weekly charts During the past week, IWM outpaced SPX and  retained its current relative strength.  According to my interpretation, this is bullish for the market, suggesting that only a minor top, at best, is being forecast by… Continued

New Short-term Target – Market Turning Points

Cycles:  Looking ahead!  90-yr cycle – last low: 1932. Next low: 2022 7-yr cycle – last low: 2016.  Next low: 2023 Market Analysis (Charts courtesy of QCharts SPX-IWM weekly charts Over the past few weeks, IWM has caught up with SPX by outperforming it.  There were signs this week that it may be slowing down as we approach the next short-term projection.  However, this does… Continued

Stocks stay very bullish into Thanksgiving – S&P 500 and FTSE 100 forecast

A firm tone seen for the main global stock indices this week, throughout November and also over the past 24 hours.The solid “risk on” theme is still been driven by:The ongoing Biden bounce, reinforced by the start of the transition of powerThe appointment of Janet Yellen as US Treasury SecretaryThe announcement of THREE very positive COVID-19 vaccine trial resultsLockdowns in Europe starting to work, with… Continued

Stocks dip but bull themes intact (S&P 500 and FTSE 100 forecast)

A dip across major global equity averages over the past 24 hours, but the underlying theme stays bullish from the very strong November rallies.The ongoing “risk on” theme has been driven by:The announcement from Moderna and Pfizer of very positive COVID-19 vaccine trial resultsLockdown measures taking hold in Europe, with falling/ plateauing in the numbers of new COVID-19 casesThe ongoing Biden bounceBut the market is… Continued

Forex Brokers in your location


72% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.


67% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.


76.4% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.